How to Get Your Offer Accepted in a Multiple Offer Situation

Joe Polyak February 14, 2018

How to Get Your Offer Accepted in a Multiple Offer Situation

Want to sell your home? Get a FREE home value report.
Want to buy a home? Search all homes for sale.

Our San Francisco Bay area real estate market is red hot right now.

We’re currently in an extremely competitive market for buyers. The number of available homes for sale is at historic lows, while the number of buyers in the market remains high.

In fact, listings are sometimes seeing 10 or more offers. But, don’t let this discourage you if you’re looking to buy.

You don’t necessarily need to submit an all-cash offer or offer the highest price to secure a home. In fact, sellers may not choose the highest offer if they feel as though that buyer isn’t going to follow through.

Today, I’ve got some steps you can take to win out against multiple offers. Here are just a few:

  1. Having underwritten approval from a lender. Whether you’re working with a large bank or a mortgage broker, you need to have a solid preapproval or underwritten approval. In our current market, this will help you present a more enticing offer. It also gives you a higher level of certainty as you move forward in the process. But, be sure to work with someone who has a good reputation in the community, since they will be communicating with other professionals involved in your transaction.
  2. Write a compelling offer letter. Most sellers have an emotional attachment to their home, especially if they’ve lived there for a long time. They want to know who will live there after they move. So, write a compelling offer letter explaining what you like about the area, what their property means for you and your family, and what made you fall in love with their home. A nice cover letter can’t make up for an otherwise unattractive offer, but a positive cover letter can definitely boost an offer from good to great.
  3. Prepare a complete offer package. Offers are written on a purchase contract. When you submit an offer, remember to include all necessary items. This includes your preapproval, your proof of funds, your cover letter, and a fully-signed disclosure package. Some agents won’t provide this last item, since it takes more work to put together. Quality agents, though, will work with you to put together a complete offer package.
  4. Present the offer in person. This advice applies more to real estate agents than it does to buyers, but it is important nonetheless. Most of the time, experienced listing agents like to work with someone they know will be professional and able to close the deal. Presenting an offer in person shows that you and your agent are committed to the transaction.
  5. Consider pocket listings. Because inventory levels are so low, you may not even find the home you like on the market. At this point, you might need to get creative. Many Realtors have what they call “pocket listings.” These properties are for sale, but aren’t listed on the MLS. Sometimes, sellers prefer to do business in a private sale rather than going through the MLS. If you are willing to look into this option, these homes can be a great alternative to on-the-market listings.

If you have any other questions or would like more information, feel free to give me a call or send me an email. I look forward to hearing from you soon.

Recent Blog Posts

Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.

Inheriting a House in California? How Prop 19 Affects Property Taxes

October 19, 2026

What heirs, trustees, and families need to know about California’s Prop 19 rules before deciding whether to move into, rent, or sell an inherited home.

Is Fall a Good Time to Buy or Sell a Home in the Bay Area? | Rise Homes

October 13, 2026

A Bay Area guide to fall real estate, including September inventory, motivated buyers, seasonal competition, pricing strategy, and year-end opportunities.

Aerial view of a home with a curved swimming pool, patio, and raised wooden deck beside mature trees.
Multiple Offers: How Do You Choose the Best One? l RISE Homes

September 24, 2026

Why the strongest offer isn’t always the highest—and how price, financing, contingencies, and certainty can determine which buyer is truly in the best position to clos… Read more

Aerial view of a gray home with a red front door, green lawn, and wooded hills.
What Happens During Escrow in a Bay Area Real Estate Transaction? l Rise Homes

September 17, 2026

A practical look at what happens after an offer is accepted, from financing and title work to signatures, funding, and the final transfer of ownership.

Home patio with outdoor dining set and arched upper window at sunset.
What Is a Real Estate Disclosure Package? Bay Area Buyer & Seller Guide | Rise Homes

September 11, 2026

What is a disclosure package in Bay Area real estate? Learn what home inspections, seller disclosures, HOA documents, and property reports buyers typically review befo… Read more

Bright living room with a white armchair beside a large grid-pane window overlooking a tree-lined street.
Should You Sell Your Home As-Is or Fix It Up First?

September 3, 2026

How strategic preparation can increase buyer appeal, create stronger competition, and help you get the best possible result when selling your home.

Dining area with a round wooden table beside corner windows overlooking a leafy neighborhood, against a brick fireplace wall.
Pre-Listing Inspections: Are They Worth It for Bay Area Sellers? | Rise Homes

August 27, 2026

Learn why pre-listing inspections are worth it for Bay Area sellers. See how upfront inspections can build buyer confidence, reduce escrow surprises, and help create s… Read more

Backyard patio with a round table, chairs, raised flower beds, and mature trees.
What Buyers Notice in the First 30 Seconds of Seeing a Home | Rise Homes

August 20, 2026

A quick look at the curb appeal, smell, and brightness details that shape a buyer’s first impression before they ever study the rest of the home.

Wooden deck with potted plants, a covered grill, and wicker chair overlooking a flower-filled garden.
Why Overpricing Your Home Can Cost You Money | Bay Area Seller Strategy

August 14, 2026

How overpricing can reduce buyer demand, weaken competition, and lead to a lower final sale price.

Let’s Talk

You’ve got questions and we can’t wait to answer them.